My Lying Lens — A Fable!

This week’s guest blogger is Michael Masters

Digital image processing has opened a whole new world of possibilities.  Every pixel is fair game for manipulation, sometimes in ways that surprise and astound.

This, of course, has launched many an ethical debate as purists and practitioners of the new order probe limits and attempt to sort out how this brave new world will coexist with the old – or not.  While there is no uniformity of viewpoint – and probably never will be – a key distinction seems to be emerging. There just may be grudging acceptance that there is a difference between photojournalism and “art” – whatever the latter is understood to be.  In the former domain, one better not add elements or remove anything.  And for good reason.  Altering reality in journalism is lying and must never be tolerated, whether verbally, via text, or in images.

Photographic art seems to receive more latitude, but with a big caveat – one ought to state up front that one does art, or at least disclose how an image differs from the original scene.  This is, of course, by no means universally agreed to.  Many stoutly refuse to go beyond traditional darkroom adjustments.  But, history tells us that photographers sought to airbrush dreary reality with the tools available even from the inception of the photographic craft, in a variety of ways too numerous to enumerate here.

These days, many do a lot more.  It is not uncommon to remove blemishes and make ugly pretty.  (Well — wedding photographers began prettying up brides as soon as they figured out how!)  Some add canvas for compositional balance.  Some blur backgrounds just as a wide open lens would.  Less approved is adding elements not there originally – unless obviously a composite.

The caveat on top of the caveat is that if one enters a contest – be it ever so artistic in character – one had better abide by the contest rules.  If the rules say no manipulation beyond X, Y and Z, woe be unto thee if you do R, Q and P.  Many judges have caught on and now require RAW files from prospective winners.  Bravo to them!

Perhaps the stickiest dilemma is the fact that one might well construe many domains to be either art or photojournalism – natural image making among them – depending on intent, ethical principles or just plain dogged opinion.  More generally, where does one draw the line?  And, who draws it? Humpty Dumpty told Alice, “When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean, neither more nor less.”  Might the most realistic answer be that we each draw our own line – and are open about what we do? 

In the spirit of Alice and Humpty, here is my modest tongue-in-cheek contribution to the debate.  Not that it will settle anything one way or the other.  Probably nothing will.  But it was certainly fun to write! 

Yesterday, I took my 800mm lens into the back yard. I waited patiently until at last a bird landed on a nearby limb. Ah, I smiled, perfect!  I took one last look at the scene before bending to the viewfinder.  Beyond the little creature, at some distance lay a hopeless tangle of decidedly unphotogenic foliage – a miserable setting to the unpracticed eye!  The bird?  Hardly worthy of notice against that chaotic background.  But, thought I, the unsuspecting naïfs who will soon view the artificiality I am about to create will never suspect the reality my eyes see at this moment!  My deceitful optical marvel will suffuse those ruinous distractions that the human eye cannot escape seeing into a beautifully unreal abstract canvas!  Poor souls!  They think I’m such a creative genius!  Little do they know I owe it all to my lying lens!  With smug, self-satisfied smirk, I placed eye to viewfinder and gently pressed the shutter.

CLICK!

Michael Masters is moderator of the Mid-Atlantic Chapter of NatureScapes.net, a web community devoted to nature photography.  As moderator, Michael organizes outings for members in the region.  A perennial favorite is Chincoteague NWR.  Michael may be reached at Michael@GrayFoxImages.com. Note: no non-traditional processing was applied to the image featured in this blog post!!

Comments: Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

 

RSS Nature Visions Photo Expo

  • Free Vendor Demonstrations – 2014 July 20, 2014
    Vendor demonstrations are free 30 – 45 minute presentations in a small classroom setting. The vendors and manufacturing reps will be on hand showing you the latest and greatest of their products. You can see how they use the software or what the products look like close up. You do not have to register for […]
    Matthew Schmidt
  • 40 Days of Africa July 16, 2014
    By Ian Plant So far, 2014 has been ridiculously busy for me. In the first six months of this year, I’ve been to 15 countries, with photography trips to the following: Venezuela, Morocco, Botswana, Argentina, Chile, Namibia, Tanzania, and Rwanda (with non-photography visits or layovers in South Africa, France, Columbia, Ethiopia, Kenya, the …read more […]
    Matthew Schmidt
  • July 2014 Night Photography Events Calendar July 2, 2014
    By Kevin Adams Each month I post a monthly night photography events calendar on the first day of the month. Events listed on this calendar are suitable for wide-field and moderate-telephoto astrophotography, as well as for general night photography. Unless otherwise stated, all events occur in the United States at mid-latitudes. Most of …read more […]
    Matthew Schmidt
  • There is More to Nature Photography than the Golden Fifteen Minutes June 30, 2014
    By Sarah Marino Seed pod. Canon 6D, 100mm macro, f/2.8, 1/200 sec, ISO 800 (handheld) One of the most prevalent pieces of advice offered to landscape photographers is also one of the most limiting: “Shoot during the golden hour.” And, if you observe a mass of photographers at some popular locations, the advice …read more […]
    Matthew Schmidt
  • The Fuji X-T1: It’s a Winner June 25, 2014
    By Justin Reznick In the first edition of my Complete Guide to Gear for the Landscape Photographer, I omitted the Fuji X APS-C mirror-less system because at the time, I felt it wasn’t built for landscape photography. That has now changed. 2014 has been a big year for Fuji and with the release …read more […]
    Matthew Schmidt

Most Viewed Pages

Archives

Nature Blog Network

Nature Blog Network